COMMUNITY REFERRAL
ONE-TO-ONE JUST MULTIPLIED
NEW TOOLS, NEW THINKING
Taking referral beyond referral and into the community
LEARN MORE
Home / Credit unions research / Iowa credit unions: similar messages, different levels of commitment

Iowa · Credit unions

Iowa credit unions: similar messages, different levels of commitment

In Iowa, the four invitation approaches sit relatively close together. The decisions about considering, opening and using an account are much further apart.

The State of Referral — Iowa Credit unions, report cover

Our Iowa research includes analysis of 1,000 existing credit-union members and, separately, 1,000 prospective customers. It examines the recommendation from both sides: what makes a member willing to speak, and how far a prospective customer’s interest extends.

The reason to act and the invitation are different questions

The reasons to act are led by a better product (28%), trust in the recommender (25%) and better rates or lower fees (22%). Cash accounts for 10%.

The product, its ongoing value and the person recommending it each address a different question. The product concerns what someone would gain. The recommender’s credibility concerns why the suggestion deserves attention. A reward adds another reason to consider the introduction.

The invitation comparison puts serious consideration at the following levels: reward at 64%; member story and trust at 62%; product fit at 62%; local community at 59%.

The four figures are relatively close. The numerical order is less striking than the amount of interest shared across all four approaches. It would overstate the contrast to describe one message as a decisive winner.

A main reason to act and willingness to consider a particular invitation need not produce the same ranking. A reward can be appealing even when it is not the main reason to take on an account. Equally, trust can make a message worth considering without removing the practical barriers to using the product.

Answering a question and starting a conversation

65% of existing members are likely to recommend their credit union if asked. The figure for initiating a recommendation without prompting is 27%.

What changes when a friend asks?

Iowa credit unions. 65% are likely to recommend if asked. 27% are likely to start the conversation without prompting.
Share of modeled existing credit union members in the Iowa report.

A question about banking gives the recommendation an immediate purpose. Starting the conversation requires the member to judge whether the subject is useful and welcome. The difference between the two figures reflects that distinction in commitment.

The leading hesitations are waiting until asked (29%), reluctance to sound like a salesperson (20%), unclear eligibility (17%) and an unclear benefit for the friend (13%).

These concerns reach beyond the mechanics of sharing. They include the social experience of recommending, the benefit to the other person and the ability to explain who can join. A good opinion of the institution can coexist with uncertainty about all three.

The experience behind the recommendation

The reasons to recommend are led by personal service (27%), trust and security (22%) and rates and value (20%). The other reasons include local connection (12%), a product that solved a need (12%) and digital ease (7%).

These reasons concern what the member values in the existing relationship. Service describes how an institution treats someone; rates and value concern the financial proposition; a useful product gives the relationship a particular purpose. The same institution can matter to different members for different reasons.

The most natural occasions for a recommendation are a friend asking about banking (34%), a relevant life event (27%) and a clear benefit for the friend (19%).

The experience and the occasion answer different questions. A helpful conversation with the credit union may provide a story worth telling. A friend’s question, a financial decision or a change in circumstances may provide the reason to tell it.

Looking, opening and using are different commitments

In the separate prospective-customer analysis, serious consideration stands at 62%. Some 37% would open and fund a suitable account, while 26% would use it regularly.

Considering an institution leaves the existing banking arrangements untouched. Opening and funding an account creates a new relationship, and regular use gives that relationship a place in everyday life. The figures become lower as the intended commitment becomes more substantial.

Readiness to move the main banking relationship now stands at 6%. Another 13% would consider moving after a trial, and 22% would use the credit union as a secondary account.

A secondary account and a trial represent forms of interest that leave room for an established main bank. They make the relationship more gradual. The consideration figure is therefore broader than immediate willingness to move the arrangements someone already relies on.

The value of changing and the work involved

The leading prospective-customer barriers are the work of switching (28%), no clear reason to move (23%) and uncertain eligibility (17%). Other barriers include too many steps or unclear terms (11%), preferring the current provider (11%) and digital or branch fit (9%).

A missing reason to move concerns the value of the new account. Switching work concerns the effort of changing arrangements. Eligibility concerns whether the relationship is available in the first place. These can all limit enthusiasm for an account, but they describe different parts of the decision.

The preferred next steps are led by comparing an account (32%), checking eligibility (22%), speaking to someone (17%) and opening alongside the current account (16%).

The next-step results give the interest a more practical shape. Comparing an account or checking eligibility resolves a question before a larger commitment. Opening alongside an existing account leaves the main relationship in place while a new one begins.

What the findings add up to

The invitation comparison is one part of the Iowa picture. It sits alongside a larger distinction between considering a credit union and intending to use an account regularly. The member’s willingness to recommend and the prospective customer’s commitment describe different sides of that relationship.

The headline figures make those distinctions concrete: 65% would recommend when asked, 27% would initiate, and, in the separate prospective analysis, 62% would seriously consider the credit union compared with 26% who would use an account regularly. The value of the research lies in understanding the different decisions behind those figures.

OVERVIEW

Customers

The flexibility of the Buyapowa platform allows you to build and manage campaigns that are tailored to the needs of your industry. Here’s how enterprise brands from all sorts of backgrounds are using Buyapowa to win more of the right customers.

Free eBook

Referral Codebreakers

Fill in the form & Unlock the science behind the world’s most successful & influential referral marketing programs.