Indiana · Residential ISPs
Indiana broadband: a recommendation needs an address and a moment
Interest in a better home connection can arrive before a household is ready to change. Indiana’s two-sided analysis separates the willingness to recommend, the appeal of a future service and the practical question of when installation could happen.

Our Indiana research includes analysis of 1,000 existing internet customers and, separately, 1,000 prospective customers, with AT&T, Xfinity and Smithville providing local context. The two sides address different decisions: whether an existing customer would start a conversation, and what someone receiving that recommendation would be prepared to do.
The clearest distinction is between future interest and present readiness. Serious consideration reaches 48% when suitable service is assumed to be available at a future decision point. Readiness to arrange installation within 30 days stands at 14%. A connection can be attractive as a future option while installation remains some way off.
Indiana makes that distinction tangible. AT&T’s home-internet options vary by address, including fibre and wireless possibilities. Smithville’s service information distinguishes fibre and DSL availability. A provider’s name is therefore only part of the story: the connection available to one household may differ from what a friend could obtain.
Being helpful when asked is different from opening the conversation
In the current-customer analysis, 47% are likely to recommend their provider if asked. The share likely to initiate a recommendation without prompting is 26%. That leaves a gap of 21 percentage points between responding to a question and starting the conversation.
What changes when a friend asks?

The distinction is about what customers would be willing to do. A customer can have a useful opinion about their broadband and still feel that the subject needs a reason to come up. Responding to a friend’s question provides that reason; introducing the subject involves another decision.
The hesitation results show more than one issue. Weak service experience accounts for 22%, while waiting until asked accounts for 21%. They are close in size but quite different in meaning. One concerns the experience available to recommend. The other concerns whether the customer would begin the conversation. Neither should be reduced to the size of a referral reward.
Uncertainty about the friend’s address accounts for 17% of hesitation. Disliking the feeling of selling accounts for 14%. A weak benefit for the friend and unclear referral steps each account for about 11%. These concerns range from confidence in the service to confidence in the invitation itself. A positive view of the provider does not settle all of them.
A local network becoming available gives the conversation a purpose
A friend asking about internet is the leading natural referral moment, at 29%. A local network becoming available follows at 25%, and a clear benefit for the friend accounts for 18%. The first two moments connect the recommendation to something specific happening in the other household’s world.
The network moment is especially relevant to how broadband choices change. An area can be associated with a provider before every home has the same options. A newly available connection can make an old recommendation newly useful. But an announcement about an area, or funding for a future build, does not establish that a particular home can order today.
Confidence about the friend’s address remains mixed. High confidence accounts for 34%, medium confidence for 41% and low confidence for 25%. Even high confidence is different from a completed serviceability check. The customer’s experience can help explain why the service is attractive; it cannot by itself confirm the friend’s connection.
The recipient has a separate decision to make
On the prospective side, address uncertainty is the largest main-barrier category, at 31%. No clear advantage and preference for the current provider each account for about 15%. Switching or downtime concerns, complex terms, and installation or property access each account for about 13%.
Address uncertainty has a clear lead within this analysis, while the remaining barriers are much more closely grouped. They describe several different questions: whether a connection is possible, whether it offers enough improvement, what the terms mean and what changing would involve. A recommendation can bring a provider into view while leaving those questions open.
The reasons to act are more evenly distributed. Lower total price leads at 24%. Better household fit and useful local support each account for about 21%, followed by trust in the recommender at 19% and cash or credit at 16%. The appeal of an invitation extends beyond a one-off benefit to the continuing usefulness and cost of the service.
These categories describe different forms of value. Price concerns an ongoing household expense. Fit concerns how the connection would serve the people and devices using it. Support concerns help when something goes wrong. Trust makes someone else’s experience relevant. Cash or credit offers an immediate benefit alongside those longer-term considerations.
Future willingness has its own conditions
The prospective outcomes assume suitable service is available when the household reaches a future decision window. Under that condition, serious consideration stands at 48%, order intent at 25% and intent to maintain active service for 90 days at 16%. Each expresses a different level of intended commitment to a future connection.
There is a 22.3-percentage-point gap between serious consideration and order intent. Considering an option leaves room for alternatives and unanswered questions. Intending to order expresses a firmer position. The 90-day measure adds another horizon, but it still concerns what the household would do under the stated future conditions.
Present installation readiness is a separate picture. For 39% of prospective customers, readiness depends on property permission or a network build. Another 14% need a later date, 33% are not ready and 14% are ready within 30 days. Interest can therefore coexist with a constraint that an attractive invitation cannot immediately remove.
That distinction matters in a market where service options depend on the home. Equipment arriving quickly, a network reaching the area and a household having permission and time for installation are different milestones. A household can be close to one of those milestones while still waiting for another.
The value of a recommendation is specific to the other household
Across the two sides, the recommendation begins with one household’s experience but has to make sense in another household’s circumstances. The current customer may be willing to help when asked while remaining hesitant about initiating. The recipient may see a worthwhile future option while having an unresolved address, property or timing question today.
The Indiana analysis brings those distinctions together. Price, fit, support and trust all appear in the reasons to act; availability and readiness shape what that interest can mean. A recommendation earns attention through the experience behind it. Whether that attention becomes an intention to change depends on the value of the service and the circumstances of the home receiving it.